Buy Cheap History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] - Sale price!
History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] Review
15 of sixteen folks found the subsequent review useful.
Something of a disappointment
By J. wensink
After having scan the primary volume of this expected series of seven volumes i used to be triggered by the thesis of those authors that ancient Greek and Roman history did in reality happen within the Middle Ages. therefore I started finding out medieval history of the center East - additionally referred to as Islamic history - to seek out out if the opponents of the traditional Greeks and Romans - the Acheamenid Persians, Sassanids, Scythians, Egyptians, etc. - even have their duplicates in medieval history. My search was disappointing: none of the various medieval Islamic dynasties appeared to correspond to the traditional middle jap rulers.
However, I did realize an in depth correspondence between Herodotus' Persian kings and medieval events:
- the defeat and capture of an Anatolian king - the Lydian Croesus - by the Persian conqueror Cyrus is a dead ringer for the defeat and capture of another Anatolian king - sultan Bayezid - by the Asian/Mongol conqueror Tamerlane;
- the Persian conquest of Egypt by the cruel tyrant Cambyses reds nearly specifically because the Ottoman conquest of Egypt by Selim the Grim (note the nickname!);
- Darius the Lawgiver of the Persian Empire appearance much alike to Sulayman the Magnificent, the Lawgiver in Islamic history;
- Xerxes, whose main claim to fame is to be defeated by the Greeks at the naval battle of Salamis, appears like Selim II (the Sot) whose main claim to fame is to be defeated by a Spanish-Italian alliance at the naval battle of Lepanto.
I ought to have expected Fomenko et al. to arrive at similar conclusions, however, they claim that the Persian kings are the alter egos of the Angevin kings of Sicily whose biographies don't contain the exploits of the Persian kings.
The similiarities I indicate result in the conclusion that Herodotus should have written his Histories at the shut of the sixteenth century. however this can be very late, providing Herodotus is "the Father of History", therefore so all alternative "ancient" histories should are fabricated even later. Yet, the founders of contemporary chronology - Scaliger and Petavius - laid their foundations additionally at the shut of the sixteenth century and had the total corpus of ancient histories already at their disposal.
It appears to me that Fomenko has got to address these inconsistencies, perhaps within the forthcoming five volumes?
Another critique of their book is that the correspondencies between completely different rulers are usually based mostly on a superficial comparison of the biographies; upon a additional thorough comparison several details seem that don't correspond the least bit.
Finally, the authors rely heavily on the works of Gregorovius (1821-1891!!) - his medieval histories of Rome and Athens - because the supply of medieval history; these works are - a minimum of within the West - hoplessly outdated and are superceded by additional up-to-date works (for instance, Julius Norwich's trilogy on Byzantine history isn't even cited).
More History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] reviews available
Read more..
Where To Buy Cheapest History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] ?
Product Details Amazon Sales Rank: #219413 in Books Published on: a pair of005-06 Original language: English Number of items: 1 Dimensions: 2.39 pounds Binding: Paperback 560 pages
Incoming search term
- History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] review
- Buy cheap History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback]
- History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] on sale
- History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] cheapest discount
- History: Fiction or Science? (Chronology, No. 1) [Paperback] black friday

0 comments:
Post a Comment